As an example of a talk using scripture, Mormon refers to scripture, and then expands and clarifies meaning. In this case, the issue is the dichotomy between action and intent. Returning to the concept of the gift, if it is not given with the correct intent, then it truly is not given. There are expectations, perhaps. The gift might be given, but with the expectation of getting something back from the receiver. When the text says that “he is counted evil before God,” we must remember that the Book of Mormon speaks in terms of polar opposites. There is God, and there is the opposite of God (the adversary, or Satan). Thus, if not of God, then it is “evil,” perhaps without the moral implications of that word.
Moving from a gift to a parallel of prayer, Mormon similarly notes that the act of praying is to communicate inward desires, and if those inward desires are contrary to God’s principles, then God does not recognize that act as true prayer.
At the conclusion of the logical reasoning section (verses 8, 9), Mormon restates that “a man being evil cannot do that which is good; neither will he give a good gift.”